These profiles briefly describe some of our projects. In addition, Phillipa Gaines has written or contributed to a number of influential reports on various aspects of the New Zealand mental health and addictions sector, many of which are not publically available.
Projects and Publications
This discussion paper highlights the key issues for the further development of the community support workforce in the mental health and addictions sector and was written by Lattice director Phillipa Gaines on behalf of Te Pou and Platform Trust. Discussions are underway on how to make progress on the issues (and actions) that have been identified in Fast Track Download... PDF (1.3MB)
Phillipa was commissioned by Platform Trust to write a report for the KPI programme sponsors in response to the sector's desire to better understand the use of social outcome indicators in benchmarking. Download... PDF (1.3MB)
On Track is the development of a Roadmap that aims to inform, shape and influence the future direction of the mental health and addiction sector. Working for Te Pou and Platform Trust, Phillipa coordinated this exciting initiative involving people from across the mental health and addiction sector and the wider health and social sectors. Read more...
A free on-line organisational self-assessment tool that is available to all community groups in New Zealand. NZ Navigator is governed by a community partnership and Phillipa project managed the tool development. Barbara was a project team member, wrote the user guides and other content, and continues her involvement with NZ Navigator as the tool's technical administrator. Read more...
Lattice Consulting was contracted by Platform Trust to update the NGO Guide to PRIMHD, an introductory step-by-step guide to the Programme for Integration of Mental Health Data (PRIMHD). We managed the project, engaged with contributers and completely refreshed the document with up-to-date information.
Download... PDF (1.7MB)
Lattice Consulting was engaged by Platform Trust to develop a publication that described the part that community non-government organisations (NGOs) take in New Zealand's Mental Health and Addictions (MH&A) service system. The activities of these essential services are explored and key facts presented.
Download... PDF (1.28MB)
The Ministry of Health contracted Phillipa to recommend a primary care information collection work plan. She produced a final report that included an overview of the evolution of the national MH&A information collection (primary and secondary care) and proposed a draft set of key performance indicators that were aligned with the Integrated Performance & Incentive Framework for primary care.
NTOM is a research project led by teams from Massey University and the University of Waikato, and funded by the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment. Phillipa was responsible for recruiting and then interviewing participants for the study from the wider Wellington region. The interviews used Q-methodology.
Platform Trust and the National Addictions Committee contracted Lattice to develop a poster to profile the work of Alcohol & Other Drug Treatment Services in NZ. Phillipa obtained a lot of the source data from the MOH and then worked with a designer to convert the information into an infographic that told a meaningful story about the AOD treatment sector. Full poster Paged version
Phillipa was the original business owner for the national collection when she worked for the Ministry of Health and has held a variety of PRIMHD related roles since 2007, including interim national PRIMHD programme manager, independent sector representative on the PRIMHD Governance Group and national coordinator of the NGO implementation project (under Platform Trust). Read more...
Phillipa facilitated all of the national mental health benchmarking forums held in New Zealand between 2009 and 2013. She developed a number of discussion documents for the National KPI project, provided expert advice and contributed to a number of project outputs. Read more...
As part of the requirements for her Post Graduate Diploma in Social Sector Evaluation and Research, Phillipa undertook an evaluation of a local DHB mental health benchmarking initiative. The study explored the use of benchmarking as a service improvement tool. The study was presented at the Australasian Evaluation Society Conference in Brisbane in 2013. Download PDF (151 KB)
The Lattice team provided an independent review of a comprehensive report that offered a comparative analysis and associated commentary of the data in six of the Director of Mental Health's Annual reports covering the period 2005 to 2011.
Te Pou was contracted to assess the effectiveness of seclusion and restraint reduction interventions and asked Phillipa to work with them to develop a programme theory to evaluate the success of the benchmarking process as a vehicle to help facilitate a reduction in the rates of seclusion and restraint.
Phillipa Gaines & Rick Williment combined forces to complete a peer review of the Draft Southern DHB Mental Health and Addiction Five Year Plan (Raising Hope) to help determine that it was ‘fit-for-purpose’ before commencing a public consultation process. Download PDF (3,212 KB)
A major organisational infrastructure provider in the MH&A sector asked Phillipa to help them redesign the way in which they engaged with and supported MH&A service providers to review their local practice and to implement change. The objective was to develop a more customer-focused approach to address the gap between what is known about what works best for service users and what staff actually do in practice.
Phillipa facilitated four local benchmarking forums for Waitemata DHB adult mental health services. These sessions involved senior managers, key staff from nine teams (inpatient and community) and representatives from a number of local NGO service providers.
Phillipa worked for the Director, MH & Addiction Service Development on a programme of work focussed on the development and use of information for quality improvement and accountability purposes. The projects included input into the development of benchmarked reports for specific parts of the MH & A system, establishment and maintenance of the benchmarking forums for NGO providers providing Community Living Services, and the drafting of the evaluation framework to support the evaluation of acute mental health services funded by CMDHB.
This project aimed to determine the extent to which the mental health and addiction initiatives that were being progressed under the auspices of “The Journey Forward: C&CDHB MH&A Service Development Plan 2005-2010” were mapped to the actions outlined in Te Kokiri (2006). Phillipa wrote the report.
The Ministry of Health contracted Phillipa to investigate the proposed establishment of a Health of Older People National Data Collection. The findings from this review provided the Health of the Older Person Policy Team with some options for data collection in the future.
Phillipa produced a stocktake report of the current information capability of a selection of the MH&Addiction NGO providers funded by C&CDHB. The findings from this initiative under ‘The Journey Forward’ supported further discussion amongst key stakeholders about the current issues regarding the production and use of information relating to mental health service delivery, specifically in NGOs.
While working for the Ministry of Health in 2006, Phillipa Gaines developed a five year strategic framework for mental health information that outlined priority areas to support current and future requirements for mental health information in NZ. Additional information is available on the MOH website. Download PDF (364 KB).
Phillipa was the national project manager for the New Zealand CAOS project. The study involved eight District Health Boards contributing data to enable the development of a national casemix classification for specialist mental health services in New Zealand. Download PDF (972 KB)
The CAOS project was the subject of a journal article: “World Psychiatry - Official Journal of the World Psychiatric Association (WPA) Volume 3, Number 3, October 2004. Developing a New Zealand Casemix classification for mental health services”. Gaines P, Bower A, Buckingham W, Eagar K, Burgess P, and Green J. Download PDF (831 KB)
A compendium to the final CAOS report was produced that presented the analysis of the outcomes data that was collated as part of CAOS. “NZ Mental Health Consumers and their Outcomes, Mental Health Research and Development Strategy, Health Research Council, New Zealand”. Download PDF (1,644 KB)
In 2001 Phillipa co-authored a national strategic framework report with Terry Huriwai. Written originally for the Health Funding Authority, the Ministry of Health report aimed to provide a national direction for the ongoing development of alchohol & drug treatment services. Download PDF (281 KB)
The 6th Australasian Mental Health Outcomes and Information Conference was held in Brisbane, 28-30 June 2017. Phillipa presented “Evidence from practice: challenging assumptions. On track - the evaluation of influence in system-wide change” at the conference.
View online presentation...
Phillipa and Ross Phillips presented a “Review of social outcome indicators” at the 2017 Platform Trust Mental Health and Addictions Leadership Day. The day aimed to provide sector leaders with an opportunity to meet together to discuss the way that the landscape is changing and to consider what lies ahead.
Download PDF (1,822 KB)
Phillipa was a presenter at the 2014 National Outcomes & Information Forum. Her session was “Social Outcome Indicators: Telling a story with numbers - what is the story that we want to tell at a population level about the contribution of primary and secondary mental health and addiction services towards the health and wellbeing of local communities, and how best do we tell this story?”
Download PDF (4,014 KB)
In 2014, Lattice Director Phillipa Gaines presented at an Australasian Evaluation Society (AES) seminar in Wellington. This presentation emphasised the use of Q-methodology and built on her 2013 paper on the same topic - “Using Q Methodology in a benchmarking evaluation.”
Download PDF (1,745 KB)
Lattice Director Phillipa Gaines presented a paper - “The role and value of benchmarking in organisational change within a New Zealand district health board” - at the Australasian Evaluation Society 2013 conference in Brisbane.
“Benchmarking has assumed an important role in the performance management toolkit. However, the evidence for its effectiveness, particularly in healthcare settings, remains inconclusive. This presentation outlines the findings of an evaluation project that employed a three-stage process to explore the conditions that helped and hindered the use of benchmarking as a service improvement tool in a New Zealand District Health Board adult mental health service.”
Download Paper PDF (337 KB)
Download Presentation PDF (1,263 KB)